Capital Commonsense
Capital Commonsense
How Do You Break Through in D.C. Politics?
0:00
-26:20

How Do You Break Through in D.C. Politics?

Rini Sampath and her former senior campaign adviser Caroline Stonecipher on what it takes to earn voters’ support.


Lightly edited for clarity.

Rini Sampath: Welcome back to Capital Commonsense. I’m Rini Sampath. I’ve been hearing from people who want a political home in DC but don’t necessarily align with DSA. So that raises a question: What do we want to offer the city, and what would it take to win people over?

I’m joined today by Caroline Stonecipher, communications lead and senior advisor on my mayoral campaign. I also want to get into the weeds about whether this comes down to pragmatism or to the candidate, the time, the money behind the message. So let’s start there. First, tell us a little bit about yourself.

Caroline Stonecipher: Thank you so much for having me, Rini. I’m really excited. I work at Evergreen Strategy Group now, helping different progressive organizations and individuals hone their communications message. Previously, I was at Boston Consulting Group working for their US CEO on her communication. I was on the Harris-Walz campaign, the Biden-Harris campaign before that, on the battleground communications team, overseeing all of the messaging in the battleground states for those campaigns.

Before that, I was in the Senate for five years working for purple and red state Democrats, and I worked in the Obama White House. My work has really been with centrist politicians for the most part, but I think even that is a pretty wide spectrum.

Rini Sampath: Let’s go into the main question: When I say “pragmatic candidate,” what does that mean to you? Does that word tell voters much?

Caroline Stonecipher: I don’t know that most voters are thinking in terms of what’s pragmatic and what’s not. I think they’re thinking about their daily annoyances. If they’re thinking about politics at all, I don’t know that they’re necessarily putting themselves in these different groups.

Maybe in a place like DC, where everyone is so political and works in politics and government and industries related to that, people have a stronger sense of identity when it comes to their political place. But I’m not sure that people are thinking in terms of what’s pragmatic and what’s possible and what’s not.

Rini Sampath: If we take a step back and look at the national level and how pragmatism is defined there, are you essentially saying that even at that national level, you would have the same opinion?

People don’t think whether it’s moderate or centrist or far left, far right. It’s really about what they need and what they desire. Would you say that’s a fair way to look at things?

Caroline Stonecipher: I think there are people in American society—the most educated voters obviously identify as Republican and Democrat. Most people think of themselves as independents, I think, and most independents aren’t actually independent. They just don’t find a home in either party.

To your question about national politics, I really do think we’re seeing a realignment right now with the midterms, where people who have voted for Donald Trump in the past are not happy with gas prices. They’re not happy with the war in Iran. They’re not happy with grocery prices. So they’re thinking, “I liked him before, but this is just not working for me right now.”

Rini Sampath: How do you think that connects at this hyperlocal level? You hadn’t, at that point when I asked you to help me with our campaign, stepped into the local level. Where did you see some similarities? We’ll get into how we honed the Fix the Basics message accordingly, but what were some of your immediate observations?

Caroline Stonecipher: It was such a great experience for me, and I feel like I learned so much working on your campaign. DC is a really interesting city, as everybody listening knows. This is probably the city with the highest number of educated voters in the country.

We really notice a disconnect between people who are extremely engaged in federal politics but really not engaged on the local level. I think we’ve seen really poor turnout in local elections in DC. People vote where they’re from because they feel like their vote doesn’t count here.

It’s created this stratified system where the people who are involved in local DC politics have a lot of power because there aren’t that many people. Then you have a bunch of people who live here who cede their vote and their opinions on local matters to those people who are involved.

Looking at those demographics and the way DC is set up, being such a Democratic city, winning the Democratic primary really being like winning the general election, I think you would expect to see a moderating effect on candidates. But that’s not really what we saw in this past election.

Rini Sampath: I want to jump into what we did see in the past election, and then we can talk about what we can speak very fluently to: how we structured our campaign comms and all that good stuff. But I do want to hear about your observations of the other candidates and your take here.

Janeese offered this very ideal vision of the city, and I think Kenyan brought a different approach. He talked a lot about his experience in city government. I think we both noticed he didn’t have a cohesive message. What’s your postmortem there?

What’s the analysis of Janeese’s message, Kenyan’s message to the voters, and how do you think their delivery either helped or hurt those messages?

Caroline Stonecipher: It’s a great question. Obviously Janeese won, so her message really resonated with people. I think she campaigned with a lot of joy and a lot of confidence and presented a vision of DC.

I think the policy position that people most associate with her is expanded free childcare, which, as we were running your campaign, we were saying, “This is not really feasible given the city’s financial situation.” But she had built relationships during her time in the city government and had, I think, built a really strong coalition. Through the DSA, I think that obviously was really helpful.

The DSA has a really strong turnout mechanism and volunteer base, so I think that helped a lot. But you could see a stark contrast between her style and Kenyan’s style. In contrast, Kenyan came off as, to me at least, really combatant.

I think it’s really tough to be the person campaigning on continuity, and we saw this on the Harris campaign too. To be the one who’s saying, “I’m going to keep the policies of the previous administration,” is tough in a time when people really want change. He didn’t campaign with the same level of enthusiasm as Janeese did, and I think there was a little bit more defensiveness, some more anger.

Rini Sampath: That makes sense. You just definitely heard one of Ted’s sneezes in the background. That is going to very nicely get picked up by my mic. I’m so sorry. For our listeners, I have an 85-pound golden retriever, Teddy, and Caroline has a 65, 60-pound golden retriever?

Caroline Stonecipher: Yes, she’s on a diet. She’s 60 pounds now. If you hear any weird background noise, that’s her chewing on her bone too.

Rini Sampath: That’s actually how Caroline and I became friends. We lived in the same apartment building, and our dogs became friends, and then we became friends. Then I decided I was going to run for mayor and drag Caroline out of a sabbatical to help volunteer on this campaign and do so many amazing things.

Back to what you’ve been talking about: Your observations have always been so helpful in helping me think about local politics. I’ve been mulling over what the future of a common sense and pragmatic candidate looks like for DC voters.

What would you suggest for a non-DSA candidate in the future? How can they really cut through to people without coming off as just trying to be a better manager of the status quo? In fact, there was a former DSA chair who tweeted exactly that at me when I suggested I’m actually a pragmatic progressive candidate. This individual said, “There’s nothing pragmatic nor progressive about wanting to be a better manager of the status quo.”

Granted, I’ll give us a pat on the back: We came in third place with $80,000 and four and a half months of running. In contrast, you had Gary Goodweather, who ran for 15 months with over a million dollars. So I think we absolutely cut through the noise and were able to offer a vision to folks.

But I really want to see a future for common sense candidates in DC, so I’m curious what your take is and what your advice would be to such candidates when it comes to their messaging.

Caroline Stonecipher: I think my thoughts on this are a little bit skewed because I’m obviously thinking in the context of your campaign and you as a candidate, which, to your point, was extremely successful.

Using that as a blueprint for anyone who wants to run as a pragmatic candidate in DC, I think one of the things you did really well was that you weren’t afraid to call out what wasn’t working. That’s something Kenyan refused to do and Kamala Harris refused to do.

To pretend everything is great is a really tough place to be. Your fearlessness in calling out the corruption in city government, the contracts we were giving people who were failing in their jobs, things like that, was really powerful.

I think we saw a really big groundswell of support for that kind of messaging, especially at the time when you announced your campaign, which was right after that snowstorm. There was ice on the roads for 16 days, people were trapped in their houses, and trash wasn’t getting picked up.

There was real frustration with city leadership at that point: “Why can’t we have our trash picked up? Why do we have all these potholes? Why are things not working?” My recommendation would be: You have to be able to call out what’s wrong, but you also have to have a plan. That’s something you did really well.

You reading all those auditor’s reports was crazy to me. But it allowed you to go into all of these really wonky conversations on so many different issues and point to real examples, to have a plan for how to fix them.

It’s really hard to take on the machine. I don’t know how to give advice for an individual pragmatic candidate. But someone who has a fundraising apparatus built in, someone who has relationships across city government—I mean, we saw a number of things that kept you out of the top-two competition, whether it was reporters refusing to cover anyone who hadn’t been on the city council, the debate moderators keeping you out, or the DC Board of Elections rules to participate in funds matching.

There are a number of structural issues. If we had announced earlier and had more money, I don’t know what could have happened. My advice for people who want to run would be: Build a plan in advance, think really strategically about all of these different timelines, and make sure—

We did such a great job with no money and no name recognition. But those things really do count, as I think we saw.

Rini Sampath: One hundred percent. I’m going to get into one of our favorite topics, which is direct-to-camera video. I feel like you had me on a strict program during the campaign, cranking these videos out, almost three to four videos a day, editing those videos. For our listeners, Caroline did the comms and was our senior advisor, but I ended up doing digital from the perspective of editing.

Caroline would give me feedback on our scripts and so forth. It was quite the production for a very tiny team. Even in the span of 30 days, when we hadn’t figured out how to boost our videos yet, we hit one million impressions.

Talking amongst DC politicos, there’s some disagreement on how much digital matters and how much door-knocking and field matters. We knocked very few doors. We didn’t have the time, resources, or money, so we used digital instead.

I’m very curious, both from your learnings on the campaign when it comes to direct-to-camera and what you are suggesting to clients today in your role at Evergreen: Can you give us some insight on where your head’s at when it comes to direct-to-camera videos and digital in the context of DC and elsewhere?

Caroline Stonecipher: It’s a really big debate in Democratic politics right now. There are traditional communications people, which is really my background, and then there are digital people. But digital is the future of communications. I think one video can get so many more impressions and so many more people paying attention than a story in a news outlet behind a paywall.

Especially when we were facing these structural issues to being covered by local media, it was super helpful. We had to introduce you to the people of DC, and you didn’t have the platform of being on the council or another local platform. So we really focused on making sure your videos would reach people and making them interesting, finding a way to hook people within the first three seconds.

We had to workshop. I’m sure you’re traumatized by this, but we workshopped so many different formats: We have a script, we have a teleprompter, we have talking points, we have you editing all of this stuff. What we landed on is that the authenticity is what resonated so well.

It’s a testament to you, because I would not recommend that every candidate do this, because not every candidate is good on camera. It’s this very specific skill set that’s different from going on TV. It’s different than talking on a panel. It’s a specific thing, and certain people just do it better than others. You were great at it.

We found that having unscripted, direct-to-camera, repeating the core message over and over again, was so important. We heard it from our friends and from people in the community: The videos were really resonating.

There are things you can do where you can pay to boost them and reach people in different neighborhoods. We had to make a calculation: We can’t afford to knock doors, so we really have to go heavily into digital, because you actually do build trust with people through these videos.

This is a crazy thing to say, but people who watch TikTok or Reels build a weird one-sided relationship with the influencers they watch. I pointed to Alix Earle a lot when we were making these videos. You are in someone’s house with them. They’re scrolling their phone, sitting on their couch or in bed, and they get to know you. You become a familiar face to them, and they do start to build trust. That was our strategy.

Rini Sampath: I wanted to hear you talk about contrast. You mentioned it during the beginning of our conversation. Now that we’re on the topic of direct-to-camera, the Kenyan and Janeese angle: Towards the end of his campaign, in an absolute state of panic, you heard him begin the contrast, but it was really negative.

How do you create contrast in messaging without being a candidate who seems to be whining about the state of society or comes off really angry, really negative? How do you think we were able to cut through that and have this likable, warm persona, I would like to think at least?

What were some of the things we did, and what are your general observations of when contrast is done well? What are the ingredients to make that happen?

Caroline Stonecipher: When we were on the Harris campaign, everything we did had to have contrast in it. That’s the mindset I was approaching this in: “These political insiders have let this happen to our city. I’m not a career politician. Here’s what I’ve done.”

Everything was: They have let this thing happen or done this, and I will do it differently. I think that’s how you can position yourself as a change candidate, as a forward-facing candidate.

We did go out super negative, as you remember, with your announcement video. I forget how many views that got in the first 24 hours, but it was something crazy, hundreds of thousands of views.

We had a pretty regular announcement video that was, “I’m Rini, and I’m running to fix the basics.” I was thinking about it that day, and I said, “We have to do something super interesting to make people take you seriously, to get reporters to pay attention, and to get people to watch this video and pay attention to your campaign.”

That’s how we flipped the message to: Our politicians have failed us. Why would you give a promotion to someone who has failed at the basic functions of their job? It was a really cutting video, and I think it really hit the frustrations people were feeling in the moment.

We actually had some of the people warning us about being too negative with our messaging. We pushed back because we were saying it’s hard to understand, when you’re not in the city, truly how angry people were after the snowstorm.

As a bunch of people who work in government, who work in policy and politics, to watch our city be governed so incompetently, I think, is super frustrating. The timing that you announced, the framing of that message being super negative in that moment, and presenting the contrast of your experience having gone into all of these government organizations and made them better was the perfect message for the moment, I think.

Part of the reason your messaging didn’t sound angry like Kenyan’s is because we contrasted it with your edits to these videos. You wouldn’t be able to do this with a Senate race or a House race, really, because I think most candidates don’t have time to do that. But your personal touch on those videos, adding in things you thought were funny, the song you were listening to at that point in time, little clips of your day-to-day stuff.

You see politicians do this really badly. You did it really authentically, and I think that could be just because of your age. But one of my least favorite things is Democratic senators posting about Taylor Swift on Twitter or making a weird, awkward direct-to-camera video.

Nobody wants to see a weird, stiff, fake-joke TikTok from an 80-year-old senator. I get that people have to try to do that, but I think making the content authentic to the person matters. This is why you see John Kennedy and Chuck Grassley—their content really resonates with people because it’s authentic to them.

In this world of AI and tech, people are really wanting to connect with things that are real.

Rini Sampath: Going off of that, I’m also curious for your take on what our presumptive mayor, Janeese Lewis George, might need to do with her comms to continue reaching people from both a hearts-and-minds perspective.

Given what we did see in the turnout for her and the base she was able to rile up, which I do think is also in part due to the progressive DSA movement across the country, there’s a lot of energy there.

But once she’s in governing mode, how do the comms shift, or do they need to shift, from what you saw on the campaign trail to what you would like to see and are expecting to see, or would even advise her to be doing, in order to be an effective mayor?

Caroline Stonecipher: That’s such a good question. I think this is really hard because governing is messy and boring and really slow. We have a great roadmap with Mamdani, and he’s done an incredible job. To some extent, her win did build off of that incredible momentum he had.

Looking at what was happening in New York over the summer with Mamdani as mayor and the Knicks winning, there was so much excitement and happiness at that time. I do think the DSA was really boosted by that.

He has done a great job since he was elected of showing progress in different things. They’re not huge things he’s doing. It’s “Filled this pothole,” or “We put the scaffolding up.” It’s one-off infrastructure things that are showing people they are actually making progress in the things that matter.

One of the first things Mamdani did was fix this bump in the road that he always biked over every day on this bridge. I think showing wins is something that’s really hard to do in government, because you’re so busy slogging through and things are getting thrown at you left and right that it’s hard to celebrate the wins.

The way we used to do that was with a press release: “Senator So-and-so secured $6 billion for this new project.” That’s not really how you show people you’re working for them anymore. I would really encourage her to focus on delivering things, even if they’re small things at the beginning.

It’s like any new job you start. The way you start out the first few months really matters to how people perceive you in that role. Focusing on some things she can fix right away would be really positive. I know she’s trying to build a broader coalition, and I’m sure she will.

I think having some wins right off the bat—and she’s going to have a challenge navigating that relationship with Trump and everything he wants to do in the city. It’s definitely going to be challenging for her, but I think they’re on the right track.

Rini Sampath: Caroline, thank you so much for joining us. Do you have any closing thoughts? I will just mention to our listeners: We’re going to have Caroline back a couple more times.

Caroline Stonecipher: I’m so excited to have this opportunity, Rini. For you guys listening, this is just what Riniand I do all the time, but at one of our apartments, drinking wine and talking about political communications, which sounds really lame when I say it.

I’ll end with this, which maybe we can talk about in the future: One of the things I’m really thinking about right now is how, in political communications at the government level, we’re taught to stay away from conflict. People are extremely conflict-averse, even in campaigns.

But one of the things I’m focused on right now is how conflict can be good. Conflict can bring attention and can be used to sharpen your message and get it out to more people.

Rini Sampath: That’s a really interesting point. I will mention I’m reading a book right now called The Art of Conflict by Priya Parker. She wrote The Art of Gathering, and I am trying to embrace exactly that. If you’re listening and you have any ideas for what you’d like Caroline and me to get into, please leave us a comment. We’re looking forward to it.

Thank you again, Caroline, for joining us, and thanks to our listeners.

Caroline Stonecipher: Thanks, Rini.

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar

Ready for more?