Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bill Lovotti's avatar

Very disappointing to hear from the presumptive next mayor. Traffic violence is a big problem in this city and it needs to be taken more seriously.

Matt Spahlinger's avatar

The full context of the quote posted on X suggests the risk to "countless workers" comes from the broader economic impact of "AI-related job displacement and disruptions", not just autonomous vehicle services. Maybe it's wrong for George to conflate them, and her whole position feels like reflexive support of Union positions, but I don't think she was referring to countless rideshare drivers living in DC.

My reflexive position is to discredit anything posted on X. Just stop using that platform.

Beyond that, I think the safety improvements on our streets from autonomous vehicle services would be very modest. The vast proportion of cars on the roads (and therefore of cars causing violence) will still be private vehicles, and they likely always will be. Why would autonomous vehicle services change a paradigm that hasn't been changed by decades of public transportation or rideshare?

And because of that sticky paradigm of private car ownership / operation, it's unclear whether a service like Waymo - which unlike Uber or Lyft owns its fleet of vehicles - can ever scale to actual utility or profitability.

Which points to the real potential threat: public subsidy of autonomous vehicle taxi services at the expense of other public transportation options. If companies like Waymo can convince cities of their absolute indispensability through dubious claims of improved safety, then they open the door to discussions of how public money can shore up their shaky finances. It's a tried and tested Silicon Valley strategy.

The proposed legislation seems to anticipate some of that trouble by effectively taxing autonomous services and directing that revenue to public transportation. Plus, the proposed licensing fees are pretty high.

So, I think a more nuanced approach from our soon-to-be Mayor would be to say, "Sure, let's fleece these Silicon Valley folks for a change while they try to compete in an open market. But they're never touching our public money on my watch."

1 more comment...

Ready for more?