On May 11, a 19-year-old rode a Lime bike into an alley off Taylor Street NW and started shooting. He fired at a parked car, then toward a home on 9th Street NW, and a bullet struck a boy in the leg as he played basketball at the nearby recreation center. Prosecutors say he fired more than 20 rounds into the neighborhood from two locations. The defendant pleaded guilty to aggravated assault and carrying a pistol without a license, and prosecutors asked for five years.
Last week, over prosecutors’ objections, he was sentenced to probation under the Youth Rehabilitation Act after spending nearly six months in jail. To be clear, the judge in this case was not required under the YRA to impose a sentence of probation, but the law does grant her greater discretion to do so in cases involving legal adults.
The lenient sentence handed down by Superior Court Judge Jennifer Di Toro caused a firestorm on social media, with Washingtonians expressing shock that recklessly shooting into a neighborhood and hitting a child could result in probation.
The case highlights a tension in how the District handles guns. D.C. has some of the strictest gun laws in the country, which I strongly support.
Most gun owners must register their firearms, and assault weapons, machine guns, sawed-off shotguns, short-barreled rifles and .50-caliber BMG rifles can’t be registered at all.
Open carry is banned, and concealed carry requires a license.
The District also bans magazines that hold more than 10 rounds. (A three-judge panel struck that ban down in March, and the full Court of Appeals agreed to rehear the case.)
Carrying a pistol without a license is a felony that can bring up to five years.
Our leaders are also right that guns used to commit crimes in the District largely come from somewhere else. Mayor Bowser once told Virginia lawmakers that illegal guns originating in Virginia are a key driver of District gun crime.
If illegal guns are the problem, our courts should treat them as such, and our Council should reexamine a law that allows leniency for gun offenses committed by adults.
The Youth Rehabilitation Act (YRA), expanded unanimously in 2018, lets judges give a more lenient sentence for defendants who were under 25 at the time of the offenses, for almost any crime other than murder and serious sexual abuse. Judges can impose sentences below otherwise applicable mandatory minimums, and eligible defendants who successfully complete their sentences can later have their convictions set aside, or essentially voided.
The Criminal Justice Coordinating Council’s report covering 2021-2025 details how the law has been used. Of the 2,533 cases that received a YRA sentence, about a third had carrying a pistol without a license as the top charge. Pistol cases were about a fifth of all YRA-eligible cases, but a third of all YRA sentences. (This report did not look at recidivism; that is coming in a future report. We have a post with more detail coming up.)
I support strict gun control. If it were up to me, there would be universal background checks, enhanced penalties for straw purchasers, limits on magazine capacity, and a nationwide ban on assault weapons with mandatory buybacks.
But the District’s gun laws mean little if there is no accountability for breaking them. A registration requirement doesn’t mean much if shooting a child results in probation.
The YRA should not be repealed wholesale. Giving young people a second chance and encouraging rehabilitation is a worthy goal and one we should continue to pursue. But it cannot result in scenarios where there is essentially no accountability for shooting a child.
Firing more than 20 rounds into a neighborhood where kids are playing basketball cannot be dismissed as simply a youthful mistake if this city takes gun violence seriously. In my view, the Council should take the YRA off the table in cases where a gun is fired, not just in cases of murder.
I reached out to councilmembers to ask whether they had any reaction to the sentence and whether the next mayor and Council should revisit the YRA.
Ward 7 Councilmember Wendell Felder responded, sharing the following thoughts: “A 12-year-old should be able to play basketball and come home safely. My thoughts are with the child and their family as they deal with the impact of the shooting. While I respect the court’s role in weighing the facts and determining the sentence, too many families in the District have lost loved ones to senseless gun violence, and our response must make clear that gun violence is unacceptable. When a person is shot, the seriousness of that harm should carry real weight in how we hold someone accountable. That accountability can go hand in hand with giving young people a meaningful chance to turn their lives around.”
He also said that the Council needs “a full picture of how the 2018 changes have worked in cases involving serious gun violence. The Council should look at how judges have used that discretion, what sentences were imposed, and what happened afterward. That review should inform whether targeted amendments are warranted and how we can strengthen accountability while preserving meaningful opportunities for rehabilitation.”
I appreciate Councilmember Felder stressing the need to understand the full impact of the YRA, particularly with respect to how Superior Court judges have used their expanded discretion. For the safety of all Washingtonians, I hope Mayor-elect Janeese Lewis George and the Council can work together on this in the next session.


