Great piece, though it did make me wonder if there's any way to align incentives between housing seekers and the voucher program, I.e. to make voucher holding housing seekers price sensitive in any way, even if less than non voucher holder housing seekers. Love the emphasis on reducing costs to allow us to serve more families off the wait-list.
Of course we know it’s federal money. You must not have read the piece. The argument is that you could serve more families with the same pot of federal money if you reduced overpayments. I’ve written before about the failures of the rent reasonableness review. https://capitalcommonsense.com/p/the-dc-housing-authoritys-rent-payment
DCHA was massively overpaying for vouchers as documented by the Post and HUD. The payment standard today is still much higher than comparable blue cities like NYC, LA, and SF. And as the piece says, we don’t have enough data from DCHA to really know how the rent reasonableness review is working.
The entire piece is predicated on the idea that the theoretical maximum amount is what is actually being approved. Did you stop to think for a second that maybe an author who from the American Enterprise Institute might not actually be honest about an affordable housing program? With Democrats like you, who needs Trump?
give me a break. your comment said that it's important for "the district to stretch every dollar." This is federal spending. But in any case, this point is secondary because the author of this piece is dishonestly arguing that, like, DC is actually approving vouchers for $3700 1 bed apartments. This claim is as fantastical as anything said at a MAGA rally.
I don't think we should spend money inefficiently just because it's federal money. Also, there are thousands of people on the waitlist and more could be served by the existing pot of federal money.
Again, the more important point here is that the numbers being cited in this article do not reflect the actual rents that are being approved for vouchers.
Mark, vouchers are paying for rent in pretty expensive buildings like The Saratoga in upper NW. The Kennedy Warren has tenants with vouchers, too. This is not a Fox News fever dream, it’s reality.
That's a good point, and yes, given the fiscal environment we're in, it's important for the District to stretch every dollar as far as possible. If more families can be housed with the same amount of money, why wouldn't we do that?
It's odd to me that you were a Senate aide and you couldn't figure out that these theoretical maximum rent amounts do not represent the rents that are actually approved for vouchers. And, even more surprisingly, you didn't know that housing vouchers are funded by the federal government, so cutting them wouldn't save DC money anyway.
Interesting piece! I’m surprised to see how high these are. It’s too bad that data aren’t available on actual rents paid by folks in the program. It seems like the rent standards are probably too high in any case, but that would be very instructive for understanding the size of the opportunity
What’s the number of folks getting vouchers for $5301? Especially since the rent reasonableness cap for a 5 bedroom is $3,768, the voucher amount decisions aren’t based on the max allowable under the standard. Keeping in mind renters are responsible for 30% and need a qualifying income for eligibility for the vouchers, I’m curious what the universe of people is (if any) receiving vouchers at that level so the savings feel purely hypothetical. I’m just not convinced lowering payment standards does anything but limit the universe of rentals.
Amazing how many people are sharing this piece. Typical libertarian nonsense. When people who despise government programs try to "reform" them, theyte almost always as misinformed as this author.
The entire argument in this piece is predicated on the silly idea that the theoretical maximum rent that could possibly be approved is what's actually being approved in practice. This is not what's happening, and anyone who actually works in indigent housing law in DC could have told you this. Heck, anyone who lives in DC could tell you poor people aren't living in ultra posh $3500 one bed apartments in Dupont Circle.
Some commenters don’t seem to think upscale areas are home to tenants with vouchers. This is from Matt Frumin’s 11/20 newsletter:
New Supports and Hotline on Connecticut Avenue
DBH and DHS have launched a hotline and placed more case managers in eight buildings along Connecticut Avenue. These buildings have high numbers of voucher holders. They have also seen increased calls to 911 and repeated incidents of tenant conduct that jeopardizes safety and quality of life. The hotline gives residents and property managers a resource for help before problems grow. On-site case managers can connect residents to services, coordinate with building staff, and identify when someone needs a higher level of care.
Throughout my time in office, I have advocated for additional resources to support voucher tenants with behavioral health and substance use challenges. These recent initiatives also respond directly to concerns expressed by residents, ANC 3F, and community advocates. More work remains, but this is progress.
Thank you for this important article. It explains something that has bothered me for years. When I was volunteering with youth in foster care, I learned that young people aging out of foster care are eligible for something called a Family Unification Program (FUP) voucher. I learned that the voucher completely covered rents in studio or one-bedroom apartments in pricey neighborhoods. In other words, while other 21-year-olds must have roommates, foster youth aging out of care who get FUP vouchers are able to live alone in fancy neighborhoods. Since these vouchers last only 3-5 years, they will eventually have to exit this alternative reality and re-enter the real world of housing prices, so the benefit for the foster youth is not clear either. Now I am thinking that these FUP vouchers probably use the same payment standards as the Housing Choice Vouchers. It would be great if somebody looked into this program as well.
Great piece, though it did make me wonder if there's any way to align incentives between housing seekers and the voucher program, I.e. to make voucher holding housing seekers price sensitive in any way, even if less than non voucher holder housing seekers. Love the emphasis on reducing costs to allow us to serve more families off the wait-list.
Of course we know it’s federal money. You must not have read the piece. The argument is that you could serve more families with the same pot of federal money if you reduced overpayments. I’ve written before about the failures of the rent reasonableness review. https://capitalcommonsense.com/p/the-dc-housing-authoritys-rent-payment
DCHA was massively overpaying for vouchers as documented by the Post and HUD. The payment standard today is still much higher than comparable blue cities like NYC, LA, and SF. And as the piece says, we don’t have enough data from DCHA to really know how the rent reasonableness review is working.
The entire piece is predicated on the idea that the theoretical maximum amount is what is actually being approved. Did you stop to think for a second that maybe an author who from the American Enterprise Institute might not actually be honest about an affordable housing program? With Democrats like you, who needs Trump?
give me a break. your comment said that it's important for "the district to stretch every dollar." This is federal spending. But in any case, this point is secondary because the author of this piece is dishonestly arguing that, like, DC is actually approving vouchers for $3700 1 bed apartments. This claim is as fantastical as anything said at a MAGA rally.
I don't think we should spend money inefficiently just because it's federal money. Also, there are thousands of people on the waitlist and more could be served by the existing pot of federal money.
Again, the more important point here is that the numbers being cited in this article do not reflect the actual rents that are being approved for vouchers.
Mark, vouchers are paying for rent in pretty expensive buildings like The Saratoga in upper NW. The Kennedy Warren has tenants with vouchers, too. This is not a Fox News fever dream, it’s reality.
It is quite obviously a fever dream. Anyone who works in indigent housing in DC could tell you that.
That's a good point, and yes, given the fiscal environment we're in, it's important for the District to stretch every dollar as far as possible. If more families can be housed with the same amount of money, why wouldn't we do that?
It's odd to me that you were a Senate aide and you couldn't figure out that these theoretical maximum rent amounts do not represent the rents that are actually approved for vouchers. And, even more surprisingly, you didn't know that housing vouchers are funded by the federal government, so cutting them wouldn't save DC money anyway.
Some vouchers in DC are funded with local tax dollars.
Interesting piece! I’m surprised to see how high these are. It’s too bad that data aren’t available on actual rents paid by folks in the program. It seems like the rent standards are probably too high in any case, but that would be very instructive for understanding the size of the opportunity
What’s the number of folks getting vouchers for $5301? Especially since the rent reasonableness cap for a 5 bedroom is $3,768, the voucher amount decisions aren’t based on the max allowable under the standard. Keeping in mind renters are responsible for 30% and need a qualifying income for eligibility for the vouchers, I’m curious what the universe of people is (if any) receiving vouchers at that level so the savings feel purely hypothetical. I’m just not convinced lowering payment standards does anything but limit the universe of rentals.
No one actually get approved vouchers at this amount, which is what makes this piece so silly.
Renters are supposed to pay 30% of their income, not the rent.
Amazing how many people are sharing this piece. Typical libertarian nonsense. When people who despise government programs try to "reform" them, theyte almost always as misinformed as this author.
The entire argument in this piece is predicated on the silly idea that the theoretical maximum rent that could possibly be approved is what's actually being approved in practice. This is not what's happening, and anyone who actually works in indigent housing law in DC could have told you this. Heck, anyone who lives in DC could tell you poor people aren't living in ultra posh $3500 one bed apartments in Dupont Circle.
HUD has a new dashboard with voucher data per authority. Lots of averages. But we can compare to other cities. https://www.hud.gov/news/hud-no-26-089
To make the discussion more actionable, maybe we should only focus on the local tax dollars spent which is about $35-40 million per year i believe.
Some commenters don’t seem to think upscale areas are home to tenants with vouchers. This is from Matt Frumin’s 11/20 newsletter:
New Supports and Hotline on Connecticut Avenue
DBH and DHS have launched a hotline and placed more case managers in eight buildings along Connecticut Avenue. These buildings have high numbers of voucher holders. They have also seen increased calls to 911 and repeated incidents of tenant conduct that jeopardizes safety and quality of life. The hotline gives residents and property managers a resource for help before problems grow. On-site case managers can connect residents to services, coordinate with building staff, and identify when someone needs a higher level of care.
Throughout my time in office, I have advocated for additional resources to support voucher tenants with behavioral health and substance use challenges. These recent initiatives also respond directly to concerns expressed by residents, ANC 3F, and community advocates. More work remains, but this is progress.
Thank you for this important article. It explains something that has bothered me for years. When I was volunteering with youth in foster care, I learned that young people aging out of foster care are eligible for something called a Family Unification Program (FUP) voucher. I learned that the voucher completely covered rents in studio or one-bedroom apartments in pricey neighborhoods. In other words, while other 21-year-olds must have roommates, foster youth aging out of care who get FUP vouchers are able to live alone in fancy neighborhoods. Since these vouchers last only 3-5 years, they will eventually have to exit this alternative reality and re-enter the real world of housing prices, so the benefit for the foster youth is not clear either. Now I am thinking that these FUP vouchers probably use the same payment standards as the Housing Choice Vouchers. It would be great if somebody looked into this program as well.